Russian Revolution vs Iranian Reaction!
vs
A Russo-Iranic Analysis
October 14, 2005
With Talent,
only given by Ahreeman (Father), to Ahreeman (Son), & via Ahreeman (Evil spirit),
Broadcasting from IPC Networks, Excellence in Iranian Net Broadcasting,
We start this beautiful morning,
Greetings to All,
Naqashol Doleh-ye Hamedani
:
I have a few comments on this topic. In my opinion, Russian Revolution, unlike Iranian Reaction of 1979, was a move forward. Why you ask?
Compare/Comparison
Tsar Nicholay Romanoff's regime was the last stop of the fast speeding train of Russian Semi-Feudal System of Tsardom, going down the drain to doom. Industrial Revolution had never fully hit Russia & Russian Empire despite the efforts of Peter The Great and then Romanoffs, never really became a full-blown industrial nation such as Britain. Russian System was a Semi-Feudal System, even @ the time of Nicholay!
On the other hand, The whole European Imperial Era was destined to come to an end. The time for European Monarchial Systems & Great Empires had come to an end. On 1917-1918 period, Monarchy was basically obsolete. Monarchy, even then, was an outdated system of government, bounded to die out. So all great empires including Russian Empire, German Empire, Austrian Empire, & Ottoman Empire died out. The only reason, Britain survived the Death of Monarchy, was due to their transformation to Constitutional Monarchy & also due to the fact that the internal system of Great Britain was basically democratic.
So basically @ this time frame, "All" Great Monarchies of the globe either died out (Historical Destiny) or they have been forced (through the years) by the masses to transform to Constitutional Monarchy, where the Monarch would become a powerless figure-head short of a puppet. @ this time or better put, by this time, democratic regimes had taken over the whole Europe.
As you mentioned, it is true that Kaiser (Wilhelm), Nicholay's Cousin, had indeed backed the Bolsheviks/Lenin & aided the Marxists to overthrow Tsar. It is also a historical fact that most leaders of Russian Revolution including Lenin & Stalin were political opportunists & they believed Ends justifies the Means; however, The Russian Revolution in its nature was a progressive move forward.
Russia was short of a Senior-Surf or Master-Peasant system where the differences between the social classes were astronomic. On 1917, Russia was basically a backwarded, superstitious & primitive nation with a powerful Military. The 1917 Russia was a Paper Empire, Glorious & Powerful from outside, but weak & primitive from inside. Russia was destined to explode & it was a matter of time for it to happen.
Russia of 1917, was unreformable. The Aristocracy, The Feudals, The Church & The Merchants were ruling Russia with an Iron Grip. They would have never permitted any substantial change.
Alexander Kerensky seized power as the prime minister & his plans where to peacefully get Tsar out of the government, transform Russia to a Constitutional Monarchy, put a puppet Tsar (maybe Nicholay's son) in government & remain as a prime minister, or transform Russia to a Republic & become the president. You may look @ Kerensky as a Russian Dr. Bakhtiar, but I look @ Kerensky as the Russian Seyed Mohamad Khatami!
You may look @ Kerensky as a vessel to peacefully transform Russia from a Despotic Monarchy to a Democratic Regime, but I look @ the history of Kerensky & see that every time it suited him, he used force, even used mass murder to push Tsar & White Russians into submission. Obviously he underestimated the power of Red Russians (Bolsheviks), their German Backups, Their Rhetorics, their popularity amongst the masses & political experience of Lenin.
I see Kerensky as an obstacle on the way of the revolution, the same as the role which Khatami played in Iran.
Actually the only thing I see in common, between Kerensky & Bakhtiar, is the fact that they were both, put in the control room, Too Late so they could do Too Little.
The Anti Democratic nature, the our way or high way attitude, the despotic behavior (Rastakhiz Party in Iran & Aristocracy in Russia), The close down of all political movements & parties, the police state environment and the Iron Hand Grip to control the government by Pahlavis & Romanoffs, eventually had prepared both nations for an explosive situation. The Explosion would have happened; it was only a matter of time.
Fortunately in Russia the explosion resulted in a Communist "Literate" & "Pro Science" regime but in Iran resulted in an Islamic "Illiterate" & "Anti Science" regime.
No matter how you look @ it, Marxists are @ least progressive, scientific, literate, pro education, undogmatic & not superstitious. Islam on the hand is reactionary, unscientific, illogical, pro ignorance, dogmatic, & superstitious. If I have given a choice to live under a Marxist or an Islamic Regime, I would have surely chosen the Marxist Regime. A Mild Disease is often better than Death!
So eventually Kerensky became the Supreme Commander of the Russian Army. His continued support for the WWI war effort made him unpopular in Russia and on 8th October, Kerensky attempted to recover his left-wing support by forming a new coalition that included more Mensheviks and Socialist Revolutionaries. However, with the Bolsheviks controlling the Soviets, and now able to call on 25,000 armed militia, Kerensky was unable to reassert his authority.
On 7th November, Kerensky was informed that the Bolsheviks were about to seize power. He decided to leave Petrograd and try to get the support of the Russian Army on the Eastern Front. Later that day the Red Guards stormed the Winter Palace and members of the Kerensky's cabinet were arrested.
Kerensky assembled loyal troops from the Northern Front but his army was defeated by Bolshevik forces at Pulkova. He remained underground in Finland until escaping to London in May 1918. He later moved to France where he led the propaganda campaign against the communist regime in Russia. This included editing the Russian newspaper, Dni, that published in Paris and Berlin.
By the way, did you know that after he pushed out of government & sent in exile, In 1939 Kerensky urged the western democracies to intervene against both communism in the Soviet Union and fascism (Nazism) in Germany?
On the outbreak of the Second World War Kerensky moved to the United States. He worked at the Hoover Institution in California and wrote his autobiography, The Kerensky Memoirs: Russia and History's Turning Point (1967). Alexander Kerensky died of cancer in New York on 11th June, 1970
It is true that Lenin was a political opportunist. It is also true that Stalin, later on killed millions in Gulags. It is also true that Communism is also a sort of Dictatorship or shall we say Dictatorship of Proletariat. But my argument with you is not about the nature of Communism or psyche of the Russian Revolutionary Leaders. My argument with you is about the fact that the Russian Revolution in general, was a move forward and it was progressive.
Russian Revolution pushed Russia into the Industrial Age, 20th century, modernization, general education, scientific progress and a new era. Tsar's Russia was a dying, Rotten, Corrupt, Ancient system of Semi-Feudal control, which was outdated & doomed to be collapsed. It was only a matter of time for some sort of a movement to end its existence.
History Repeated!
Now you can witness the resemblance of the 1917 situation with the 1990 situation. In late 80s & early 90s, @ the Fall of Communism in Russia, once again the "Historical Destiny" took control! The Marxism was bound to fall. The Communist Russia, the same as the Tsar's Russia, became obsolete.
If Monarchy was outdated in 1917, the same way, Communism became obsolete in 1990! Once again, Russia became a paper Empire! USSR (CCCP) was basically a third world nation with a magnificent military, space program & open minded sexual relations! Once again, Russia could not compete, she became primitive (compare to west), corrupt, poverty stricken & ready to explode.
It was the historical destiny (Jabr-e Tarikh) for CCCP to die out the same way that the Monarchy died out! @ that point, Communism was as outdated as the Monarchy.
Russia and Iran
Now compare the Russian situation of 1917 to Iranian situation of 1979. Shall we?
Similarities:
Romanoffs were corrupt, Pahlavis were corrupt.
Nicholay was out of touch with the masses, Alahazrat was out of touch with reality!
Nicholay's information about the country came from Aristocracy; Alahazrat's info came from SAVAK & the Ass Kissers around him.
Nicholay was weak; he fled to save his neck, Alahazrat once again, same as 1953, betrayed Iran & Iranians & fled like a coward.
Nicholay's Earl was a weak, ill & unqualified boy; Alahazrat's Earl was another Ahamd Shah, totally worthless to replace him.
Nicholay's superstition, lack of freedom & social injustice caused the explosion, Alahazrat's Islamic superstition, police state, gap between social classes resulted in explosion.
Romanoffs, except Nicholay were corrupt; Pahlavis except Alahazrat were rotten!
Nicholay had Orthodox superstition & favored the Church, Alahazrat was a superstitious Muslim & jailed/murdered all opposition except Muslim/Mullahs, whom eventually destroyed his regime!
Nicholay's spouse was entrapped by Rasputin & superstition; Alahazrat's spouse is also prisoner of her superstition, connecting herself & her son to Imam Hassan & Hussein as Seyedeh of Hassani & Husseini (that famous web page, which Empress Farah took it off the net, only after I mocked the whole concept in public)!
Nicholay had court jesters around him; Alahazrat had Ball Polishers, Hand Kissers & Ass Kissers around him!
Nicholay isolated democratic, nationalist, true servants of Russia; Alahazrat distant himself from Knowledgeable Technocrats, & Democratic Free Thinkers.
Foreign Powers (Germany) contributed to Nicholay's fall, Foreign Powers (CIA, MI6) contributed to Alahazrat's fall.
Nicholay cared about his country, Alahazrat loved his nation.
Marxism made Russia a super power; Shiite made Iran a Regional & a Continental Power.
Marxist Russia was highly ideological; Shiite Iran is highly ideological.
CCCP ended up in corruption & poverty; IRI is corrupt & economically challenged!
CCCP exported ideology (Marxism), IRI is exporting ideology (Islam).
Differences:
Russian Empire was unreformable but Imperial Iran was reformable.
Russia was corrupt to the bone, but Iran was badly corrupt, yet not to the bone!
Kerensky was a power hungry opportunist, but Bakhtiar was a Nationalist & Iran's final hope for salvation.
Fundamental of Russian Revolution despite its leaders, was revolutionary & progressive, but fundamental of Iranian Reaction including its leaders were reactionary & backwarded.
Kerensky was a block to the revolution, but Bakhtiar was the final hope to stop the reaction.
Kerensky's Duma Boys were positively motivated but without the means to make a positive tribute, but everyone in Jebhe Meli back stabbed & abandoned Bakhtiar & kissed Imam's Ass for power, position & money!
Duma Boys were concerned about Russia, but Jebhe Meli leadership were charlatan opportunists.
Nicholay was basically living off of Russia & maintaining Status Q, but Alahazrat was devoted to Change & done many goods for Iran.
Kiss Asses around Nicholay abandoned him @ the end, but the Kiss Asses around Alahazrat, until the final moment, were trying to misguide him about the complete nature of the situation & realities of Iran.
Nicholay did not betray the people around himself, but Alahazrat betrayed close friends, he jailed Hoveyda as an escape goat, abandoned the military & fled to save his own neck!
Russian Revolution resulted in Marxism which educated people so they peacefully reformed Marxism to Democracy in early 90s, but Iranian Revolution resulted in Shiite which further turned people into Religious Cattle; therefore, the masses are & will be drowned in Shiite Water (An-Abeh), until the day that a Social Revolution can change the fundamentals of Iran!
Marxist Russia promoted Education, Secularism, Federalism, and Science, but Shiite Iran promotes Ignorance, Historical Illiteracy, Quran, Ali Bazi, Theocracy, Global Terrorism, Central Government Control, Religious Garbage, and pure Shiite for brains!
CCCP lost the star wars & armed race; IRI has lost the international community's respect!
CCCP promoted highly intelligent leaders, e.g.: Brezhnev, Gorbachev ....., but IRI promoted highly Shiite for brains leaders, e.g.: Khomeini, Khamenei, ........Third Up_Cuming Imam!
So as we see, there are similarities & differences between CCCP & IRI.
But the fact remains that Marxism Educated the Russian Masses but Islam has only brought Shiite & placed piles of it in Iranian's heads, instead of brain!
Marxism due to its secular nature promoted science in Russia but Islam due to its theocratic nature promoted Shiite Ala Carte in Iran.
So generally, we conclude that
Russian Revolution in general was progressive (in comparison to Tsardom Russia).
Iranian Reaction in general was Reactionary (in comparison to Imperial Iran).
Marxism pushed Russia forward.
Islam pushed Iran backward & under in Deep Shiite.
Russians became Educated through Marxism.
Iranians became Full of Shiite through Islam.
Our Challange
As you know,
I am neither a Monarchist or a Muslim
I am neither Aristo_Imperialist or a Marxist
I am too Monarchist to be a Republican, and too Republican to be a Monarchist!
But if,
Monarchists of today, are these Up_Position Leaders/Feeders, Media Lords, Cheesy Website Owners, TV Talk Show Hosts and TV Movements,
and if,
Republicans of today, are opportunist, con artist, charlatan, fake baboons who sell their mothers for $5, such as Jebhe Meli Iran,
Then by all means, exclude me from both these buffoons and their groups! Both of these groups (Monarchists + Jebheis) are so bloody insecure & so Anti Freedom of Speech & so afraid of the other party's voice, or the masses to be educated by the truth, that both parties are masters of Censorship, shutting people up or not even allowing any other voice aside themselves to even talk!
Take a look @ their cheesy Internet forums Jebhe Meli, SMCCDI, other Crap........
Take a look @ their Daily or Weekly Rag Papers & Ragazines in LA & London ..............
Take a look @ their cheesy TV Talk Shows & TV Movements ...............
Every single one of them are talking their talk & not listening to anyone else. Every single one of them censors everyone else except their own. Every single one of them is Vajihol Meleh & has a remedy to cure Iran's problems. And every one of them has a group of uninformed cattle who follow them & wave their pictures & Iranian Flag!
They All sing:
Ey KIRan, Ey Marze por ze Khar.............
Look @ each & you will see a Nationalistic facade,
But look deep into their eyes,
you will see a Dictator waiting to be born!
My friend, you know how the saying says: It's All Good?
Now I must reluctantly say: It's All Bull Shiite, It's All Shiite!
As you mentioned, it will take @ least 4 generations to educate these people! Why?
We must educate the masses, we must educate the instructors who educated the masses, we must educate the intellectuals who educate the instructors who educate the masses, we must educate the leaders who educate the intellectuals who educate the instructors who educate the masses! We have to practically educate everyone in this God For Saken Nation!
We must educate all of this doomed tribe to the true meaning of Democracy, Freedom of Speech, Freedom of Press, People's rights to express themselves, Secularism, Federalism, Science and Human rights!
Many are schooled, yet only a few are truly educated!
My friend, by the time we educate all of these Leaders, Intellectuals, Instructors and The Masses..........., we will be 444 years old! And I doubt that we will live that long! But what we can do is to draft Mass Media, specifically Internet as a tool to get through to "All". We need to fundamentally clean up the Shiite from "All's" brains & replace it with "Logic". My friend, do not think for a second that Dictatorial thought patterns due to Old Shiite Traditions & living in Islamic Societies are exclusive to Muslim! Not @ all indeed! Muslim, Monarchist, Jebhei, Mojahed, Socialist & even Marxist Iranians are "All" infected with this Iranian Disease & with this "Allahic Virus" which infects "All" despite the religious, political & philosophical ideologies! They All want to shut others up & preach their tune in the manners of:
Morshed O Morid
Naqal O Pa-Manbari
Luti O Antari
Mullah O Tolab
Each believes that the only way to succeed is to grab a Hammer & Bang on Others heads & then Force Manhandle the cattle! Ride Them Out, Gather All, Ride Em In, Raw Hide...... Eeh Haw, Hee Haw! That's The Iranian Thought Pattern!
I got a little ditty for you:
"Khariyyat na tanha alaf khordan ast,
Balke ba Miran O Mirani zistan ast!"
I rest my case.
On The Lighter Side
PS:
I dig GB (Ghorboonesh Beram) which you have invented.
I could have also invented JB (Jigaresho Bokhoram); however, I am destined to stick with my legendary Alias of GF (Gold Finger) aka "Angosht Tala", due to the fact that the first year class of Junior High & then the whole Kharazmi Junior High, in Tehran, granted me the title, for Fingering the voluptuous Art Teacher, right in the class! I still remember the thrills of deep fingering the Art Teacher (back then a Tehran University Student)! In those tender ages of Pre-Teen-hood, it was surely valiant, dangerous & pleasureful to Finger an older woman. First she grabbed my ear & kicked me out of the classroom, but on the next class, due to my extreme juvenile charlatanism, innocent face & Angel-like behavior, she bought it that I could have not possibly even have the knowledge or capability to commit such outrageous crime!
I fooled the teacher, assistant principle & everyone else in administration, so they all forgave me, thinking that it must have been some other degenerate student, who fingered the art teacher, yet I got the blame, due to my mature outlook, physical/height & simply by being tall. I was standing outside the class @ the next session, informing the Art Teacher of how the assistant principle had discovered my innocence & the way that it is impossible for a naive child like me to commit such despicable crime! Amazingly, the Art Teacher bought it or maybe pretend that she bought it! I was sad looking, ashamed & looking down to the ground, so she ended up making me feel better by actually hugging me, kissing me on the lips & telling me with her soft voice that: "I understand"! Student body were jumping over each other's shoulders, getting next to the window to witness this passionate kiss! They could not believe what they have seen!
I believe the Art Teacher, deep inside, knew of my Evil Nature, Con Artist Outlook & Award Winning Performance as a naive child, yet she was overwhelmed with my boldness, action & Oscar Winning performance, so she went along with it & she forgave me; furthermore, she grasped me as a favorite student!
Only, I could Finger the Art Teacher, & then instead of getting expelled, I would have received a Kiss on The Lips by her, as a thank you note for Fingering her! And that's why the news spread like a storm in Kharazmi JH, then # 1 and even to other Kharazmi branches! After that day, I have become a Junior High Legend. The legend of the "Gold Finger"!
So maybe I should stick with GF as a Neo Alias, no?!
Who celebrates your Camaraderie?
Who truly loves you Admzad?
Who appreciates your talent?
Who cherishes your brain?
Who loves you baby?
Ahreeman indeed!
Who else?
Folks,
I am having so much fun in IPC,
If I only had more fun than this,
Then it would have been a sin!
Until next time,
Ahreeman Bless You All.
Amen!
Sincerely,
Evil1