February 28, 2005 = 2564 Shahanshahi PIY (Persian Imperial Year)
Before you read this post, review the Updated Version:
Zoroastra and Zoroastrianism, the Real Story
http://iranpoliticsclub.net/philosophy/ ... /index.htm

Zarathustra Spitmata the great Persian Philosopher - Contemporary Image
Zarathustra Image is from:
Persian Mythology, Gods and Goddesses (3 Parts)
http://iranpoliticsclub.net/culture-lan ... /index.htm
The time has come for us to finally write a truth based, historically accurate and scientifically based document about Zorastra and Zoroastrianism! May the Truth be revealed and The Light of knowledge spreads around. Shall we begin?
Zarathustra's Timeline
The ongoing historical debate on the exact timeline of the birth and life of Zarathustra Spitmata will never end! There is basically a difference of opinion which varies about 1000 years. There are tens of different versions by tens of different historians! Allow me to mention a few different theories.
Myth Based Theories
These theories are often based on Persian mythology, Shahname Ferdowsi, and other epical myths
Greek Testimonial Based Theories
These theories are often based on Greek myths and Plato Era documents. These theories date the time line of Zarathustra some millennia before the fall of Troy and the Trojan wars.
Archeological Based Theories
These theories study the various archeological discoveries. Some try to compare Gathas with Rig Vedas, because Sanskrit and Gathic languages are the branches of the same mother language. A factor has been taken into account which is, the Aryan migration from the northern lands (Siberia and or Caucasus) towards the Persian plateau and the Indian sub-continent. These theories are not accurate to figure the exact date but they can be considered the best approximations on the time line of Zarathustra.
Historical Based Theories
These theories compare the social aspects of life during Zarathustra (as reported from the Gathas) and compare it with the first accurately known times, mainly, the Achaemenian period, and then figuring out a date. But the point is that Gatha has been tampered with, over and over through the years.
Traditional Based Theories
These theories are based on Pahlavi of the Bundahishn, one of the Zoroastrian scripture written around the time of Arabo_Islamic invasion_occupation of Persia, The scripture was written either during the Sassanid or after the invasion. Overall the scriptures state that Zarathushtra was born in 588 BC, stating that this was 258 years before Alexander’s Invasion_Occupation of Persia.
Various Other Theories
A number of historians use other methods and come up with post Achaemenian dates, which are now for facts, proven to be inaccurate.
Why don't we review some of these timelines by various historians:
Legend:
Zarathustra's Timeline Dates (BC), Source Historian
Myth Based Theories
10,000 Manly Palmer hall
7129 H.S. Spencer (The Aryan Encyclopedia)
6600 J.K Katrak, Shahname Ferdowsi
6312 Pithawala
Greek Testimonial Based Theories
6480 Xanthus of Lydia (5th century BC)
6350 Eudoxus & Plinus quoting Aristotle, 6000 years before Plato (4th century BC)
6200 Hermodorus (3rd century BC)
6000 Hormazdyar Mirza (Outlines of Parsi History quoting Greek scholars)
6000 Plutarch
Archeological Based Theories
6000 - 4000 Kavosji and Bharucha
3500 Firouz Azargoshasb (Chicago lecture 1981)
2000 Hippel & Lassen
2000 Asgarov (based on excavations in Uzbekistan, 1984)
2000 - 1500 (based on Rig Veda and Aryan migration 1700 - 1500 BC)
1800 - 900 Moulton
1767 Zabih Behruz (based on various astrological techniques)
1700 - 1400 J. Ashtiyani (based on Gathas and the Rig Veda)
1500 Mills (first 900 BC, and later changed to 1500 BC)
1400 - 1000 Mary Boyce (A History of Zoroastrianism, 1989)
1200 - 1100 Thomas Burrow (based on Farvardin Yasht and other post Zarathushtra scripture)
Historical Based Theories
1080 Pour Davoud (The Age of Zarathushtra, Journal of KR Cama Institute, 1935)
1080 Shapour Shahbazi (based on post Alexander Persian historical records)
1000 Dastur M.N. Dhalla (history of Zoroastrianism, 1938)
1000 Hummel (based on Assyrian inscriptions)
1000 Lommel (based on Egyptian papyri)
1000 - 900 Wesendonk
1000 - 600 Gherardo Gnoli (based on Gathic and Achaemenian Scripture)
900 Bartholomae and Widengren
Traditional Based Theories
660 - 583 E.W. West (Pahlavi Text, part 5, Oxford, 1897)
650 - 541 W.B. Henning (Zoroaster, Oxford, 1947)
570 - 550 Herzfeld (Zoroaster and his World, Princeton, 1947)
589 - 512 Anquetil du Perron (Zand Avesta, Paris 1971)
588 Bundahishn (based on Bundahishn, Alexander's Invasion_Occupation of Persia)
Various Other Theories
458 H.S. Nyberg (Die Religionen des Alten Iran, 1938)
100 Darmesteter
Zoroastrian Calendar
Zoroastrian Calendar is also an issue of controversy amongst the historians. There are three Zoroastrian calendars of Fasli, Shahanshahi, and Qadimi.
Fasli Zoroastrian Calendar
Fasli means seasonal. This is a religious calendar which is based on seasons by calculating one day every four years, patterned after the Gregorian Armenian calendar. Nowruz, The Persian New Year is fixed on March 21.
Shahanshahi Zoroastrian Calendar
Shahanshahi or Shenshai means Imperial. This calendar is used by Parsi Zoroastrians, including some of the most influential Mubed-e Mubedan (Top Zoroastrian Priest), Mubeds (Zoroastrian Priests) and generally, Dasturs (High Priests). It is based on a religious calendar which was theoretically synchronized with the seasons by calculating a month every 120 years, but the calculation was not consistently followed on. Nowruz was observed on August 23. A recent proposal would reform the Shahanshahi calendar by bringing it back into harmony through the calculation of whole months.
Please note that "Shahanshahi Zoroastrian Calendar" is different than "Shahanshahi Calendar" (Persian Imperial Calendar) aka PIY. The "Shahanshahi Calendar" is based on coronation of Cyrus The Great 559 BC and starting of The Persian Empire to replace the Median Kingdom. IPC uses this calendar.
Qadimi Zoroastrian Calendar
Qadimi means old and ancient. In 1746 Dasturs in Surat adopted the Irani calendar on the basis that it represented an ancient tradition. The Qadimi calendar is one month ahead of the Shahanshahi.
So as you see, it comes down to many theories.
Theory One
According to certain Zoroastrian Fire Temples and Mubeds, Zarathustra was born on 1777 BC and the Zoroastrian Calendar is based on his 40th Birthday, so right now, the year is 3742 Zoroastrian Holy Year.
Theory Two
According to other Zoroastrian Fire Temples and Mubeds, the Zoroastrian Calendar has a base year 631 AD, the year of coronation of the last Zoroastrian Sassanian king, Shahanshah Yazdgird III. So right now the year is 1374 AY (Avesta Year).
Theory Three
Then you have other Mubeds claiming that in post-Sassanid Persian astronomy books, Zarathushtra built an observatory in Zabol, Sistan (eastern Iran) and that it was inaugurated on 21st March 1725 BC, the day King Vishtasp and his court converted, chose the Good Religion of Zoroastrianism and joined the Zoroastrianism Fellowship. It also provides us with the clue that the Good Religion was founded by Zarathustra, exactly twelve years earlier on vernal equinox of 1737 BC.       Â
And the list goes on and on, and each Fire Temple based in India (Parsis) or Iran (Yazd) or America (Orange County) or etc., has their own beliefs!
What do I believe?
Zarathustra Spitmata's Birthdate is on Farvardin 6th, - 71 Shahanshahi = March 26th, 630 BC. And, Zarathustra Spitmata's timeline is 630 BC - 550 BC. He was born on this glorious day. Why you ask? Because after studying all the above testimonials, analysis of historical facts, study of archeological discoveries, latest scientific debates, I chose to have a progressive approach and view history as a science; therefore, I shall state that this is the most logical conclusion based on the latest evidence.
Zarathustra could have not been born way back in 1000 BC or before, simply because back then Iranians had Mithraism and Vedaiism Religious beliefs. Beside some mythical documents such as Shahname, there is no solid evidence that there was a trace of Zoroastrian Beliefs back then! Even early Medians had no clue of Zoroastrianism! Median Kingdom (728 BC - 550 BC), only started to grasp Zoroastrian values in later years of the Kingdom. Eventually the Achaemenid Court after 559 BC (Coronation of Cyrus), started to fully grasp the concept of Zoroastrianism.
There is a difference between actual historical evidence and myths of Shahname or Hierarchy of various Zoroastrian Temples! Mubeds, Zoroastrian Temples and Shahname are not evidence of true history!
Zarathustra Spitmata
The Timeline of Zarathustra will remain in debates and questions! Also many scholars believe in various different birth place for him! No one exactly knows where or when the Zarathustra was born. Some scholars put his birth in western Iran, perhaps near Tehran, others due to the eastern Iranian dialect and language of his poetry, place his birthplace in the east (Khorasan). Some place his birth in Troxiana between Amu Darya River (Oxus) and Sir Darya River (Jaxartes), near Aral Sea (Aral Lake) in North East of Persian Empire, Soqdiana (Today's Uzbekistan). Then of course, you got some who believe he was born in Atropategan (today's Azerbaijan), most likely in City in Shiz.
Some consider him an Azeri. For those who believe Zarathustra was Azeri, I must clarify a few points. Back then, Atropategan (Atropatgan) was a Khashtarah (State) of the Median Kingdom. Ancient Atropats were a world different than today's Azeris. Ancient Atropats were Median Aryan but Today's Azeris as a majority are mixture of Turk (Turkish Race) + Persian (Median Aryan), and as a minority are Semi Aryan (2/3 Aryan). Ancient Median Atropats were a totally different story than today's Turkish Azeris!
As for the date of his birth, it has been a matter of controversy forever (as stated above). Some Greek sources placed him as early as 6000 BC, few if any scholars take that date seriously. The traditional Zoroastrian date for Zarathushtra's birth and ministry is around 600 B.C. This is derived from a Greek source that places him "300 years before Alexander" which would give that date; other reasonings behind the 600 BC date, is that King Vishtasp of Zarathustra's Gathas is actually the father of the Persian Achaemnid King Darius I, who lived around that time.
The Meaning of The Name
Zoroaster, is a Greek term of the name Zartosht. Zarathushtra, which means, in ancient Persian, "yellow camel."
Zarathushtra = zara (yellow or gold) + ushtra (Ushtor, Shotor, Camel).
So
Zarathushtra = Referred to as "The Owner of the Gold Camel" or "The Golden Camel"
Animals such as camels and horses were essential and even sacred to the people of Zarathushtra's Era and thus a name containing one of these animals marks a person as important. A similar naming practice occurred among the ancient Greeks where names containing "-ippos" or horse denoted high birth, such as Philippos (lover of horses), Aristippos (best horse), or Xanthippos (yellow horse). So as you see, it is not a put down to call Zarathushtra, the Golden Camel or Owner of the Golden Camel.
The later Hierarchy and Bureaucracy of The Zoroastrian Fire Temples, perhaps embarrassed by their prophet's primitive-sounding name, stated that the name meant "The Golden Light," deriving their meaning from the word zara (gold) and the word ushas (light or dawn).
There is no doubt about Zarathushtra's clan name, which is Spitama - perhaps meaning "white."
Spitama = White or White Race or White man
So:
Zarathushtra Spitama = The White Man who owns The Golden Camel
or
Zarathushtra Spitama = The Golden Camel of The White
The Evolution - Transformation of the Zarathustra's name
Through the history of Persian Language,
Pahlavi Avestai
Pahlavi Sassanid
Colonial Persian
Modern Persian
the name has transformed:
Zarathushtra (Ancient Persian) => Zartosht (Persian) => Zoroaster (Greek) => Zarathustra (Western)
Spitama (Ancient Persian) => Spitman (Persian) => Espitmata (Greek) => Spitmata (Western)
Zarathustra's Family
Zarathushtra's father was named Pouruchaspa (many horses) and his mother was named Doqdu or Duqdova (milkmaid).
Zarathustra is said to have had six children, three boys and three girls. This is not confirmed as history, because the number, equals of the six Amesha Spentas (Amshaspanadan Angels) and may be only symbolism. Gatha is supposedly composed for the marriage of Zarathustra's daughter "Pouruchista" (Great Wisdom) so he is known to have had at least one child. Zarathustra, in the legends, had three wives (in sequence) of whom the last was Huvi (Hovi or Hvovi meaning Prime Cattle or owner of fertile cattle) the daughter of King Vishtasp's prime minister. Zarathustra married into the king's court; Pouruchista, in turn, married the prime minister of the court.
Zarathustra's Life (Historically Accurate)
There is a little biographical evidence in the Gathas. Whatever there, indicates that Zarathushtra was out casted from his original home, wherever that was, and forced to wander and move about without a fixed course, along with his followers and their animals.
Zarathustra and his followers wandered around until they found a sympathetic friend such as King Vishtasp, who was in fact not the father of King Darius Achaemenid, but an earlier ruler of the same name, who may have lived in eastern Iran or in Bactria (today's Afghanistan). There, Zarathushtra won over the king, and his court, and became the court's spiritual inspiration and guru. He was basically the philosopher poet of the courthouse. There is also not much accurate historical information about Zarathustra's life and times in the courthouse. Some say it was here that he composed the Gathas, which the names of king and his court appears in his poetry.
Zarathustra most likely spent 30 years in Vistasp's court before his death at age 80 or so. Some say he got murdered by Anti Vishtasp forces and some say he died of a natural cause. According to my studies, he has died of the natural cause.
The Reality of Zarathustra
Historically, Zarathustra Spitmata, has never ever claimed that he is the prophet of Ahuramazda or God!
He never refereed to himself as a prophet. He always referred to himself as a simple poet or a writer. The fact was that he was a great philosopher poet, way ahead of his time and era. Reading of Historical Documents, zoroastrian Texts, Avesta and Gathha with a deep historical analysis does teach us the same.
The Fantasy of Zarathustra
The Grand Hierarchical Bureaucracy of The Zoroastrain Fire Temple, Mubed-e Mubedan and Mubeds, have created fantasies of Zoroastra's Prophethood! The Fire Temples & Meqs (Zoroastrian Priests), like any other Organized Religious Hirarchy, have fabricated stories such as:
Zarasthustra's mother, Doqdu glowed with the divine Glory. The soul of the prophet Zarathustra was placed by Ahuramazda (God) in the sacred Haoma plant (which Zarathustra condemned in the Gathas) and the prophet was conceived through the essence of Haoma in milk (though the birth which is not a virgin birth, but the natural product of two special, but earthly parents.). The child laughed at his birth instead of crying, and he glowed so brightly that the villagers around him were frightened and tried to destroy him (envy and superstitions). All attempts to destroy young Zarathustra had failed; fire would not burn him nor would animals eaten him. Some say he was grown up by a mother wolf in the wilderness! Zarathustra then spent years in the wilderness searching for God before his first vision, in which Vohu Manah came to him in the form of an Amshaspand (Angel). All the heavenly entities, the Amesha Spentas (Amshaspandan) , declared Zarathushtra as prophet in heavens, and he received perfect knowledge of past, present, and future. Zarathushtra's preaching's to King Vishtasp was enhanced by some miracles, especially the healing of a paralyzed horse that convinced the king to accept the new religion and many other superstitions and stories about Cattle!
According to the 'Zend Avesta', the sacred book of Zoroastrianism, Zoroaster was born in Azerbaijan, in north west Persia. He is said to have received a vision from Ahura Mazda, the Wise Lord, who appointed him to preach the truth.
Of course in today's Zoroastrian Fire Temples, we witness many progressive preachers and scholars who deny all these Mumbo Jumbo and only stick with the fact that Zoroastra was prophet of God and lived as a Meq (priest).
Either progressive or fanatical beliefs of the various Fire Temples, they are both fabricated stories made up by High Priests of the Temple, away from historical realities. Through millenniums, Zoroastrian scripture has been tampered with and fabricated.
Zarathustra's True Teachings
Zarathushtra was never divine, he was only a man but a progressive man, a poet and a philosopher. His teachings were basically:
Good Thoughts (Pendare Nik)
Good Words (Goftare Nik)
Good Deeds (Kerdare Nik)
The Good and Evil are there for you to chose. The choice is yours. The man chooses his own destiny without the fear of burning in hell in afterlife (Shiite Islam)!
Avesta, Gatha and Zoroastrian Scripture, teach us many goods about Zarathustra and his ways. We can learn many goods about Zoroaster's philosophy and poetry through these documents.
Fore more information, go to IPC Library and read these books in Persian and English.
IPC Library
http://iranpoliticsclub.net/library/index.htm
also read:
On Faravahar, The Persian Zoroastrian Icon & Ancient Iranian History:
The Meaning of IPC Colors & Emblem
Faravahar, Green, White and Red
http://iranpoliticsclub.net/culture-lan ... /index.htm
8000 Years of Iranian History (7 parts)
http://iranpoliticsclub.net/library/eng ... /index.htm
Zoroastra & Zoroastrianism, The Real Story!
But the point is that Organized Religion had created a prophet out of Zarathustra! Zorostrian Fire Temple, the same as all other Mosques, Churches, Synagogues, Buddhist Temples, Hindu Temples, other Temples, are businesses who sell salvation.
There is no doubt that there are some good decent High Zoroastrian Priests and Scholars out there, but the majority are businessmen! The scientific reality is that:
* God is a myth, an invisible big guy sitting up in the sky ruling the world that he had created!
* Prophets of God were all charlatans, some were ahead of their time and very wise but still charlatans!
* Saints and Imams were all Con Artists!
* Holy Men are all Businessmen!
* Worship Temples are place of business!
But in comparison, today, many Fire Temples, unlike other places of worship, do not beg for money to sell salvation! They state a lot of historical facts, teach a lot of good, and avoid mumbo jumbo miracles and story telling. Whoever wants to donate money, they will do it behind the scene and anonymous. There are many rich zoroastrians who support the Fire Temples.
Conclusion
Facts
I. Zarathustra was a great philosopher poet, ahead of his time.
II. Zarathustra was a great Persian and human being who taught us many goods.
III. Zoroastrianism is a Persian philosophy, not a Holy religion.
IV. There are only two people amongst the prophets, who have never claimed to be prophets of God, one was Buddha and one was Zarathustra. That's why I respect both of them as great philosophers and I truly have not much respect for rest of the prophets, thus they were a bunch of miracle sellers, magicians and con artist frauds. I respect Buddha due to my Martial Art philosophy of Kung Fu and Meditations; I respect Zarathustra because he was pure thought!
V. Iranians and in general global public have limited minds and they are in need of some kind of God, Prophet and Religion. Evolution is too scientific for these folks! Therefore, in Iranian's case, we cannot simply take away Islam from them and leave them with nothing! They are like lost children & they will collapse! Therefore, we shall replace the more logical, realistic philosophy of Zoroastrianism with Islam. Besides, Zoroastrianism is a Persian Philosophy unlike Islam which belongs to Arabs and enemies of Iran! People often ask me why IPC emphasizes this much on Faravahar and Zoroastrianism? People also ask me why an Atheist such as yourself emphasizes so much on zoroastrianism? That's why!
VI. If Iranians must have a religion, then Zoroastrianism is far better and progressive and more Persian than the fanatical reactionary cult of Shiite Islam! Please observe:
Cult Characteristics
1. The Leader, The Divine Guru
2. The Use of "Controlling" Techniques such as Fear of the above, conversion and afterlife
3. Social and Physical Isolation
4. Extremist or Fanatical Behavior
5. Secrecy and Deception
and they are all present in Shiite Islam.
Lets value and study our rich Persian Heritage. Lets value our Persian Icons such as Zarathustra Spitmata.
For more information, please observe
IPC Calendar
http://www.localendar.com/public/AhreemanX
In these days of fear and indecision forced upon us by the AIOG (Arabo_Islamic Occupational Government), lets safeguard our great icons such as Zarathustra and our great classical Persian Philosophies such as Zoroastrianism.
Zarathustra Spitmata, may his great spirit rests in peace.
Yes my friends,
Many are schooled, yet only a few are truly Educated!
To be Persian, means to Live as a Free Persian, to love Persian, and to Die as a Proud Persian.
Pure Persian Pride
Amen
AX